THE PIZZA OF YOUNGSTOWN
since 2012
Fresh Daily
Pizza
Eat Good Pizza.
THE PIZZA OF
Youngstown
Avalon Downtown Pizzeria is the perfect place to gather with family, friends, and neighbors. With generations of tradition baked into every pizza, soups from scratch, and meals done the right way — we are the Pizza of Youngstown.
We’re a family-owned and operated restaurant in downtown Youngstown. If you’d like to learn more about our history and love for Youngstown restaurants, including our dedication to serving great pizza in Youngstown, click below.
Brier Hill Pizza
THE AVALON WAY
At Avalon Downtown Pizzeria, we’re proud to serve authentic, handcrafted pizza rooted in Youngstown tradition. From our classic recipes to bold new favorites, every pizza is made fresh, right here in the heart of Downtown Youngstown.
One of our most iconic offerings is the Brier Hill Pizza—a local favorite that started in Youngstown’s Italian neighborhoods. We stay true to the original with thick tomato sauce, roasted peppers, and Romano cheese, all baked on our signature focaccia-style crust. Craving something heartier? Our Loaded Brier Hill Pizza kicks it up with spicy sausage and hot peppers. It’s a bold, flavorful take on a Youngstown classic—crafted the Avalon way.
other ways
TO ENJOY
Do you want to enjoy Avalon Downtown Pizzeria’s pizza fresh from the oven, but in the comfort of your own home? Or perhaps you want to upgrade the food at a work or family function? Avalon offers take & bake pizzas and catering services to meet your needs! Whether you’re looking for takeout in Youngstown or catering for a special event, give us a call.
WHAT’S
THE
SOUP?
Avalon has fresh soups made from scratch, daily. Stop-in, check our online ordering, or call to learn today’s soup.
Visit Us
downtown
Enjoy local feel-good, eat-good pizza from Avalon Downtown Pizzeria. We use the best and freshest ingredients to ensure you get the finest pizza in Youngstown.
Mon – Thurs : 11AM – 9PM
Fri – Sat: 11AM – 2AM
Sunday: Closed
for the team of
Youngstown
At Avalon Downtown Pizzeria, we’re proud to stand with Youngstown State University as the Preferred Pizza Partner of YSU Athletics. This partnership is more than just about pizza—it’s about supporting the Penguins and the Youngstown community that we’ve called home for generations.
We know Youngstown shows up. Whether it’s on the field, in the stands, or around the dinner table, we bring that same grit and pride to every pie we serve. From pre-game fuel to post-game celebrations, Avalon is where Penguins fans gather to share in the wins and the tradition of this city.
This isn’t just pizza—it’s a slice of Youngstown history, made fresh for every fan who calls this city home. Swing by Avalon Downtown and taste what keeps Youngstown going. Go Penguins!
ALWAYS FRESH
We Believe in Quality
So, what makes Avalon Downtown Pizzeria the Pizza of Youngstown? Walk in the door and find out. You get dedication to authentic Italian immigrant tradition — soups are always made from scratch, exacting standards for all of our cheese, and a crust that takes four hours to make every morning. From wedding soup with egg croutons, fried dough sprinkled with sugar, to the beloved Brier Hill Pizza — Avalon makes it right. Hungry yet? Check out our menu here!